Home | Carnegie Learning
Back to BlogIs It Magic, or Just Math?

Is It Magic, or Just Math?

Teaching the ‘why’ and not just the ‘how’ builds deeper understanding, problem-solving and analytical skills in our kids.

I recently noticed a video making the rounds on Facebook: Japanese Multiplication - Multiply Using Lines (Math Trick)

Pretty cool, right? It might even seem like magic.

In reality, this technique is not as different from the "traditional" one we're used to as you might think.

When you draw the lines, you are performing the same multiplication as you might otherwise.

Calculate the 1s place of the product:

Multiplication 1 x 3

Calculate the 10s place of the product:

Multiplication 3 x 2   Multiplication 2 x 1

Calculate the 100s place of the product and add everything together:

Answer is 483

In the Japanese example, the lines that are drawn represent different values: 1s, 10s, and 100s. When you draw the lines and count their intersections, you are performing the exact same multiplications and additions as you did in the traditional method:

Counting 3 intersections   Counting 8 intersections   Counting 4 intersections   Answer is 483

In fact, you might ask yourself: Why does the traditional way work? It can also seem magical, but it’s simply an issue of place values. For example, the 42 must be shifted over to the left (rather than directly under the 63) because it is actually 420, not 42.

My son’s in fourth grade, and he's being taught to break it up like this to understand the 'why' beyond just the 'how' (the formula):

Twenty-one twenty-threes is twenty twenty-threes plus one twenty-three: 21*23 = (20+1)*23 = 20*23 + 1*23. And twenty twenty-threes is twenty twenties plus twenty threes: 20*23 = 20*(20+3) = 20*20 + 20*3.

Both of the above “magic methods” end up doing exactly the same multiplications and additions that we arrive at by breaking up the problem in this intuitive way: 20 × 20, 20 × 3, 1 × 20, and 1 × 3.

This type of conceptual understanding will help my son as he solves problems -- mathematical or not -- in the future. It’s really great to see how it’s become second nature to him to break up complex problems into simpler parts!

What About Math Homework That's Different From What We're Used To?

 

Parents can get frustrated when their children come home with math assignments that they don't understand and can't help with. When that happens, it’s important to remember that just because something was always done a certain way doesn’t mean it’s the best way to do it! Teaching the ‘why’ and not just the ‘how’ builds not only deeper understanding in our kids, but problem-solving and analytical skills that they will use throughout their lives.

You never know -- you might even learn something from your kids if you let them explain their math homework to you!

Author

  • Matt McHenry
  • Senior Software Developer
  • Carnegie Learning, Inc.

Matt is a Senior Software Developer on Carnegie Learning’s Intelligent Tutoring Systems team. He’s been with Carnegie Learning for 18 years, and has worked on pretty much every part of the MATHia platform at some point during that time. He enjoys spending time with his family, biking, coding, and swing dancing in his spare time.

Explore more related to this author

You May Like

Success Spotlight: Teacher Creativity Shines in Texas Middle School…
Karen Sloan
10 Essential Steps for Launching a Spanish for Spanish…
Maggie Thomas
10 Reasons TNI Is the Best Educator PD Event…
Emily Anderson, PhD
8 Tips FOR Women in Leadership, FROM Women in Leadership
Danielle Donnelly
Success Spotlight: Phonisha Hawkins Re-Energizes Math Education at Spring ISD
Karen Sloan
Top 10 Reasons Students and Teachers Should Celebrate International…
Amy Takabori
  • February 06, 2018

Parents can get frustrated when their children come home with math assignments that they don't understand and can't help with. When that happens, it’s important to remember that just because something was always done a certain way doesn’t mean it’s the best way to do it!

Matt McHenry, Senior Software Developer, Carnegie Learning

Filed Under

  • LONG + LIVE + MATH
  • Teaching Strategies

Tags

  • 21st Century Skills
  • Instructional Approach
  • Math Fun
  • Parents
  • Problem-Solving

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Carnegie Learning, Inc.

  • 501 Grant Street
  • Union Trust Building
  • Suite 1075
  • Pittsburgh, PA 15219
  • P: 888.851.7094

© 2014-2023 Carnegie Learning, Inc.

Home | Carnegie Learning Close
  • Home
  • Solutions
    • Math Solutions
    • Middle School Math Solution (6-8)
    • High School Math Solution (9-12)
    • MATHia (6-12)
    • MATHiaU (Higher Ed)
    • Zorbit’s Math (K-6)
    • Zulama Coding (6-12)
    • Literacy Solutions
    • Mirrors & Windows (6-12)
    • Fast ForWord (K-12)
    • Bookshop Phonics (K-5)
    • World Languages Solutions
    • ¡Qué chévere!: Spanish (6-12)
    • En voz alta: Español para hispanohablantes (6-12)
    • T’es branché?: French (6-12)
    • Deutsch So Aktuell 8e: German (6-12)
    • Zhēn Bàng!: Chinese (6-12)
    • Amici d'Italia: Italian (6-12)
    • World Language Immersion (6-12)
    • Exploring (6-8)
    • Symtalk (K-5)
  • Services
    • Professional Learning Services
    • High-Dosage Tutoring
  • Why CL
    • Research & Results
    • Success Stories
  • Company
    • Careers
    • Events & Webinars
    • Press Room
    • Blog
    • Communities
  • Let's Talk
  • Blog Listings
  • Sample Center
  • Help Center
  • Customer Sign-in